When it comes to roofing materials, homeowners and contractors often find themselves faced with a plethora of options. And while you might know the difference between the various roofing materials, you may be less familiar with the brands that produce them.
Two prominent names in the roofing industry are GAF and CertainTeed, both renowned for their quality shingles. With a wide variety of benefits to each one, it can be difficult to determine which one is right for you.
We’re here to help simplify that choice, by breaking down:
- Their pros and cons
- Cost considerations
- Product offerings
- Warranties
By the end of this article, you’ll be better equipped to make an informed decision when it’s time to replace or install a new roof. GAF vs. Certainteed...which one will come out on top?
Pros and Cons of GAF Shingles
Not all asphalt shingles are created equal. It is important to do your research so that you get the best deal for your home. As one of the industry’s leading brands, GAF has a lot to offer…and some clear downsides, too.
✅ Pros:
- Reputation and Experience: GAF, founded in 1886, boasts over a century of roofing experience, making them one of the most trusted names in the industry. Their longevity and track record speak volumes about their commitment to quality.
- Wide Range of Options: GAF offers an extensive selection of shingle styles, colors, and materials, ensuring that homeowners can find the perfect fit for their aesthetic preferences and budget.
- High-Quality Materials: GAF shingles are often praised for their durability and weather resistance. They use advanced technologies like Advanced Protection® Shingle Technology to enhance the performance of their products.
- Wind and Impact Resistance: GAF’s Timberline® ArmorShield™ II and Timberline® HDZ™ shingles are known for their exceptional wind and impact resistance, making them a reliable choice in areas prone to extreme weather conditions.
❌ Cons:
- Higher Price Point: The quality and reputation of GAF shingles come at a cost. They tend to be more expensive than some other shingle brands on the market.
- Installation Costs: Due to their weight and complexity, GAF shingles may require professional installation, which can add to the overall cost.
Pros and Cons CertainTeed Shingles
As GAF’S #1 competitor, CertainTeed shingles are not to be overlooked! Here are some of the biggest pros and cons.
✅ Pros:
- Variety of Styles: CertainTeed offers a diverse range of shingle styles and colors, allowing homeowners to find a shingle that complements their home’s architectural style and personal taste.
- Affordability: CertainTeed shingles are often considered more budget-friendly compared to GAF, making them an attractive choice for cost-conscious homeowners.
- Eco-Friendly Options: CertainTeed offers eco-friendly shingles like Landmark Solaris® and Landmark Pro Solaris® that are designed to reflect more sunlight, reducing the amount of heat absorbed by the roof and potentially lowering energy bills.
- Easy Installation: Some CertainTeed shingle lines are designed for easier installation, which can translate into lower labor costs if you’re hiring a contractor.
❌ Cons:
- Durability: While CertainTeed shingles are generally durable, they may not have the same level of performance as some premium GAF options in extreme weather conditions.
- Warranty Variability: CertainTeed offers various warranties depending on the specific product and installation method, which can be confusing for consumers. It’s important to carefully review the warranty terms to ensure you understand the coverage.
Cost Comparison
When it comes to cost, GAF’s asphalt shingles tend to be on the higher end of the price spectrum. The exact cost can vary significantly depending on factors like the shingle style, material, and location. On average, GAF shingles can cost between $100 to $150 per square foot, including installation.
CertainTeed shingles, on the other hand, are generally more budget-friendly. Prices can range from $70 to $120 per square foot, including installation. This cost advantage makes CertainTeed an appealing option for homeowners on a tighter budget.
It’s essential to keep in mind that while GAF shingles may be more expensive upfront, their longevity and superior performance can potentially offset the initial investment over time. Consider your long-term roofing needs and budget when making your decision.
Product Offerings
Both GAF and CertainTeed offer a range of shingle products to cater to different needs and preferences.
GAF Products:
- Timberline® Shingles: GAF’s flagship line, known for its quality and durability. Options include Timberline® HDZ™, Timberline® American Harvest®, and Timberline® ArmorShield™ II.
- Designer Shingles: GAF offers designer shingles like Grand Sequoia® and Camelot® II for those seeking a premium look.
- 3-Tab Shingles: GAF also provides economical 3-tab shingles like Marquis WeatherMax® for budget-conscious homeowners.
CertainTeed Products:
- Landmark® Shingles: CertainTeed’s most popular line, offering a wide range of color options and good durability.
- Landmark Pro® Shingles: An enhanced version of Landmark® with added durability and aesthetics.
- Presidential Shake® Shingles: Premium shingles designed to mimic the look of cedar shakes for a luxurious appearance.
- Solar Reflective Shingles: CertainTeed offers solar reflective shingles like Landmark Solaris® and Landmark Pro Solaris® for energy-efficient roofing solutions.
Warranty Comparison
Understanding the warranty offered by each brand is crucial, as it can provide peace of mind regarding the longevity and performance of your shingles.
GAF Warranty:
GAF offers robust warranty options, including:
- Limited Lifetime Warranty: Many GAF shingles come with a limited lifetime warranty, which covers manufacturing defects for the lifetime of the shingles.
- Wind Warranty: GAF offers wind warranties of up to 130 mph or higher for their premium shingle lines, depending on the specific product and installation.
- StainGuard Plus™ Algae Protection: Some GAF shingles include a warranty against algae staining for up to 25 years.
CertainTeed Warranty:
CertainTeed’s warranties can vary depending on the product and installation method. They offer:
- Limited Lifetime Warranty: CertainTeed typically provides a limited lifetime warranty on their shingles, which covers manufacturing defects for the life of the shingles.
- Wind Warranty: CertainTeed offers wind warranties ranging from 60 mph to 130 mph, depending on the specific shingle and installation.
- Algae Resistance Warranty: CertainTeed offers warranties against algae staining for various durations, typically ranging from 10 to 15 years.
It’s important to note that warranty terms and coverage can change, so it’s essential to review the specific warranty documents for the shingle product you choose. Additionally, both manufacturers may require specific installation and maintenance practices to maintain warranty coverage, so be sure to follow their guidelines closely.
Work With a GAF Certified Contractor
In the battle of GAF vs. CertainTeed shingles, the right choice ultimately depends on your budget, aesthetic preferences, and regional weather conditions. GAF shingles are renowned for their quality, durability, and extensive product offerings but come at a higher price point. CertainTeed shingles, on the other hand, are more budget-friendly and offer a variety of styles, making them an excellent choice for cost-conscious homeowners.
Whatever brand you choose, it is important to find a contractor who knows their way around the particulars of that style of shingle. At Johnson Restoration, we’re proud to be a GAF Master Elite contractor with the knowledge and skill to install a roof that will last. Contact us today to get an estimate for your roofing project!
